10 Best Eyebrow Pencils 2025 in the UK

The NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil in Espresso is an excellent choice for those looking to achieve natural-looking eyebrows with precision. Its dual-ended design includes an ultra-thin mechanical pencil and a spoolie brush, making it easy to draw, shape, and define your brows. The color Espresso provides a deep, rich shade that's perfect for users with darker hair tones. Its vegan formula is a bonus for those seeking cruelty-free beauty products.

One of the pencil's strengths is its ultra-fine tip that allows for fine, hair-like strokes, which is ideal for filling in sparse areas without making them look overly drawn. This is particularly useful for those with over-tweezed brows or naturally sparse areas. The pencil is also praised for its long-lasting formula, ensuring that your defined eyebrows will stay intact throughout the day without requiring frequent touch-ups.

However, some users might find the texture slightly too soft, leading to quicker wear-down of the pencil tip, which can necessitate more frequent repurchases. Additionally, while the finish is natural, those with very oily skin might find that it does not stay on as long without setting it with a brow gel or similar product. In terms of ease of use, the mechanical nature of the pencil means there's no need for sharpening, which is convenient for everyday use. The spoolie brush on the other end lets users easily blend the pigment, leading to a seamless, natural finish. This product is particularly well-suited for individuals with normal skin types who prefer a natural finish and are conscious of using vegan and cruelty-free makeup products.

The Rimmel London Professional Eyebrow Pencil in Dark Brown is a versatile product that aims at enhancing and shaping eyebrows with ease. One of its standout features is the intense color pigmentation, offering a dark brown shade that suits a variety of skin tones and hair colors. This makes it appealing for those looking to achieve a natural-looking finish.

The pencil format is easy to sharpen, ensuring a precise application every time. It's complemented by a built-in brush applicator, which allows for blending and smoothing out the pencil strokes to achieve a polished look. Users will appreciate the non-sticky formula, which promises comfortable wear throughout the day. This is particularly advantageous for individuals with all skin types, as the product is designed to be long-lasting, reducing the need for frequent touch-ups.

However, while the product touts benefits like long-lasting wear and natural finish, it may require some practice for beginners to achieve the perfect application, as with any eyebrow pencil. The texture is generally smooth, but some users might find it slightly waxy, which can affect precision if not applied carefully.

An added benefit is that the ingredient list is natural and silicone-free, and the product is not tested on animals, which will resonate well with conscious consumers. Weighing just 1.4 grams, this pencil is also compact and ideal for on-the-go applications.

In essence, this eyebrow pencil is a practical choice for women seeking an affordable and reliable option with a touch of sophistication, especially those who favor natural-looking eyebrows that are well-defined and long-lasting.

The Maybelline Express Brow Ultra Slim Defining Eyebrow Pencil in Medium Brown is designed to give you natural-looking brows. The color 04 Medium Brown is versatile and suits many skin tones, providing a subtle yet noticeable enhancement to your eyebrows. The pencil has a fine 1.5mm tip which allows for precise application, making it easy to define and shape your brows.

The texture of the pencil is smooth, helping it to glide over the skin without pulling or tugging, which makes it suitable for all skin types. Additionally, the retractable design is user-friendly, reducing the need for sharpening and making it convenient for on-the-go touch-ups. Another strength is the built-in brush which helps to blend and feather the product for a more natural finish.

It delivers a matte finish which is ideal for a more understated, everyday look. However, while it is shatterproof and silicone-free, some users might find the longevity of the product less impressive compared to more premium options, as it may require touch-ups throughout the day especially in humid conditions. Nonetheless, with a high customer satisfaction rate reflected in its reviews, this eyebrow pencil is a solid choice for those seeking a reliable, easy-to-use product for natural-looking brows.